905-780 3262

Heat Pump vs Electric Fireplace: Which Is Better for Toronto Homes?

Toronto homeowners seeking cozy comfort during our long winters often consider either a heat pump or an electric fireplace for supplemental heating. But which option offers more efficiency, value, and year-round usability? Here’s a comprehensive comparison from the experts at Temperature Care.

How Do They Work?

Electric Fireplace:

Plug-in or hardwired appliance that mimics the look of a wood or gas fireplace
Produces heat using electric coils and a fan (usually up to 5,000 BTUs/hour)
Heats a single room, not the whole home
Offers visual ambiance with LED “flames,” but is primarily decorative

Heat Pump (Mini-Split or Ducted):

Uses electricity to move heat into (or out of) your home
Can heat and cool one room, a zone, or your entire home
Delivers even comfort, top efficiency, and includes air filtration/humidity control

Learn more: ENERGY STAR – Heat Pumps

Efficiency & Cost Comparison

Feature	Heat Pump	Electric Fireplace
Heating & Cooling	Yes (heats and cools)	Heating only
Heating Area	Whole home or multiple zones	One room/area
Efficiency	200–350% (COP 2–3.5)	100%
Air Quality	Filters, humidity control	Can dry air, no filtration
Operating Cost	Much lower (per sq ft)	Higher for whole home use
Ambiance	Functional, less visual	Decorative, flame effect
Rebates	Substantial (see below)	Not eligible

Heat pumps use less electricity per unit of heat and can cool your home in summer.
Electric fireplaces add atmosphere and fast heat in one room but aren’t designed for primary heating.

Compare: Clean Energy Canada – Heat Pump Savings

Comfort & Air Quality

Heat pumps:
- Deliver steady, even warmth and cooling
- Filter and circulate air for a healthier home
- Perfect for allergy sufferers or anyone seeking year-round comfort
Electric fireplaces:
- Warm up quickly, but only in the immediate area
- Can dry the air and create hot/cold spots
- Best for ambiance and short-term comfort

Installation & Rebates

Heat pumps:
- Professionally installed, wall-mounted or ducted options
- Eligible for generous rebates:
  - Canada Greener Homes Grant
  - Enbridge Home Efficiency Rebate Plus
Electric fireplaces:
- DIY installation, just plug in or wall mount
- No rebates available

See Temperature Care’s heating & cooling services

Which Should You Choose?

Choose a heat pump for the most efficient, year-round heating and cooling, and healthy indoor air.
Choose an electric fireplace for supplemental heat and decorative ambiance in a specific room.