Heat Pump vs Propane Furnace: Which Heating System Is Right for Your Toronto Home?

If you live on the outskirts of Toronto, in cottage country, or anywhere without access to natural gas, you may use a propane furnace for home heating. With energy costs rising and more government incentives for clean tech, is it time to consider a heat pump instead? At Temperature Care, we compare both systems to help you make the best choice for comfort, savings, and the planet.


How Do They Work?

Propane Furnace:

  • Burns propane (stored in a tank) to generate heat
  • Distributes warm air via ducts
  • Known for fast, powerful heating—even in extreme cold

Heat Pump:

  • Uses electricity to move heat from outdoors inside (and vice versa for cooling)
  • Provides both heating and air conditioning
  • Modern cold-climate heat pumps are designed to work reliably even at –25°C

Learn more: Natural Resources Canada – Heat Pump Systems


Efficiency and Cost

FeaturePropane FurnaceHeat Pump
Efficiency80–98%200–350% (COP 2–3.5)
Operating CostHigh (volatile propane prices)Much lower (especially with Ontario’s hydro)
Heating OnlyYesNo—also cools in summer
Fuel SourcePropane (delivered)Electricity (grid)
  • Heat pumps deliver more heat per dollar, and can cut heating bills by half or more compared to propane.
  • Propane furnaces are simple and effective but tied to fluctuating fuel prices.

Compare: Clean Energy Canada – Heat Pump Affordability


Environmental Impact

  • Propane furnaces: Burn fossil fuel, releasing carbon emissions and requiring regular deliveries.
  • Heat pumps: Minimal direct emissions, especially green with Ontario’s clean electricity grid.

See: US DOE – Home Heating Emissions


Comfort and Convenience

  • Heat pumps offer consistent, even heating, humidity control, and built-in cooling for summer.
  • Propane furnaces provide rapid, high-temperature heating, but no air conditioning.

Government Rebates and Incentives

Toronto-area homeowners switching from propane to a heat pump can claim substantial rebates:

Ask Temperature Care to help you maximize your rebates and savings!


Installation Considerations

  • Switching to a heat pump may require electrical upgrades or changes to your ductwork, but most homes are compatible with either ducted or ductless (mini-split) heat pumps.
  • Old propane tanks should be removed if not used for other appliances.

Learn more: ENERGY STAR – Ductless Systems


Which Is Right for You?

  • Choose a heat pump for lower bills, year-round comfort, and the smallest carbon footprint.
  • Keep propane only if your area lacks reliable electrical supply or you need emergency backup heating.

Why Choose Temperature Care?

  • Toronto experts in propane and heat pump systems
  • Clean, professional installations
  • Support with every step: rebates, permits, aftercare

Read about our services


Contact Us for an Honest Assessment

📞 905-780-3262
Book your home evaluation online


External Resources


Share the Post:

Related Posts