905-780 3262
For homeowners outside downtown Toronto—or in cottages and rural properties—propane heaters are still common. But with rising fuel costs and cleaner technology, heat pumps are quickly becoming the preferred choice. Which system delivers the best balance of comfort, cost, and environmental impact? Let’s compare with insights from Temperature Care.
How Do They Work?
Propane Heater/Furnace:
- Burns propane stored in outdoor tanks
- Provides strong, quick heating through ducts or portable units
- Requires regular propane deliveries and tank maintenance
Heat Pump (Air-Source):
- Uses electricity to move heat into (or out of) your home
- Heats in winter, cools in summer—one system for all seasons
- Works with ducts (whole home) or ductless mini-splits (zoned comfort)
Learn more: ENERGY STAR – Heat Pumps
Efficiency & Cost Comparison
| Feature | Heat Pump | Propane Heater |
|---|---|---|
| Heating & Cooling | Yes (year-round) | Heating only |
| Efficiency | 200–350% (COP 2–3.5) | 80–95% (modern furnaces) |
| Fuel Source | Electricity | Propane (delivered fuel) |
| Operating Cost | Much lower long-term | Higher, volatile propane prices |
| Rebates | Major (see below) | Rarely eligible |
- Heat pumps save thousands over time thanks to high efficiency and hydro-powered electricity.
- Propane prices are unpredictable, and tank rentals/deliveries add hidden costs.
Compare: Clean Energy Canada – Heat Pump Savings
Comfort & Air Quality
- Heat pumps:
- Gentle, even heating and cooling
- Quiet operation, humidity control, and air filtration
- Great for allergy-sensitive households
- Propane heaters:
- Powerful blasts of heat, effective during cold snaps
- Can dry out the air
- Storage tanks take up outdoor space
Environmental Impact
- Heat pumps: Ultra-low carbon emissions—especially with Ontario’s clean electricity grid.
- Propane: Burns fossil fuels, producing greenhouse gases.
US DOE: Heating System Comparisons
Installation & Rebates
- Heat pumps:
- Professional installation required
- Eligible for major rebates:
- Propane heaters:
- Easy replacement for existing propane systems
- Few or no rebates available
See Temperature Care’s installation services
Which Should You Choose?
- Choose a heat pump if you want year-round comfort, rebates, and lower bills.
- Choose propane only if you live off-grid or in an area with unreliable electricity supply.
- Hybrid systems (heat pump + propane backup) are also an option for peace of mind.
Why Trust Temperature Care?
- Specialists in both heat pump and propane heating systems
- Unbiased advice tailored to your home’s needs
- Full rebate support and professional installation
Contact Us for Expert Advice
📞 905-780-3262
Book your free consultation online
External Resources
